Melbourne’s Athenaeum Theatre has welcomed One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest to the stage, with Jason Donovan leading an outstanding cast in a production that delivers plenty of laughs alongside some genuinely heartbreaking moments.
Based on Ken Kesey’s novel and adapted for the stage by Dale Wasserman, the story takes place inside a psychiatric institution, where the patients live under the strict supervision of Nurse Ratched. Their established routines are soon disrupted by the arrival of Randle P. McMurphy; a rebellious newcomer who has little interest in following the rules. Directed by Roger Hodgman, the production explores the relationships between the patients, the people responsible for their care and what happens when someone begins challenging the way things have always been done.
Jason Donovan shines as Randle P. McMurphy, bringing an incredible amount of energy and humour to the role. McMurphy is an unapologetic attention seeker, and Donovan makes the most of every opportunity to command the room. Whether he’s deliberately pushing someone’s buttons or finding new ways to cause trouble, there’s a loveable charm beneath his behaviour that makes it difficult not to warm to him. Donovan is constantly entertaining, and his ability to switch between comedy and the more serious moments of the story makes for a fantastic performance.
Opposite Donovan is Nadine Garner as Nurse Ratched; whose presence is felt throughout the entire production. Garner brings a level of authority to the role that makes it difficult to focus on anyone else when she’s on stage. Even in scenes where Ratched is absent, there’s an awareness of her influence over the patients and their behaviour. It’s an impressive performance, particularly in the exchanges between Ratched and McMurphy, where their opposing personalities become increasingly difficult to reconcile.
Jeremy Proulx delivers another standout performance as Chief Bromden, bringing an enormous amount of emotion to a character who spends much of the production observing those around him. Proulx is captivating, with the smallest moments carrying as much weight as the larger ones. There’s something particularly moving about the way he delivers his dialogue. Every word feels considered, and when Chief Bromden does speak, you find yourself hanging on to everything he has to say. It’s a beautiful portrayal that becomes increasingly important as the story progresses.
The supporting cast, including Gyton Grantley as Cheswick, David James as Harding, Daniel R. Nixon as Billy Bibbit and John Xintavelonis as Martini, round out the production wonderfully. The relationships between the patients are a large part of what makes the story work, with the ensemble providing some of the evening’s funniest moments as well as its most upsetting. Each character contributes something different; helping to create a group of people whose lives you become invested in over the course of the performance.
What makes One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest particularly effective is how naturally it moves through such a wide range of emotions. There are moments of genuine hilarity followed by scenes of sorrow, frustration and tragedy. At times, it feels less like watching a traditional story unfold and more like being given a glimpse into the everyday lives of these characters. Yet, despite its two and a half hour running time, the production flies by.
There’s a great deal to appreciate about this adaptation, from Donovan’s larger-than-life performance and Garner’s commanding presence to Proulx’s deeply moving portrayal of Chief Bromden. Together with a wonderful supporting cast, they make for an exceptional night at the theatre.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is funny, emotional, tragic and ultimately incredibly moving. We highly recommend catching this production before its limited Melbourne season comes to an end.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is playing at the Athenaeum Theatre, Melbourne, until 20 December 2026. Purchase your tickets here.
Photo Credit: Eugene Hyland

