Seven years after their last Melbourne visit, Death Cab for Cutie returned to Margaret Court Arena on Friday night with their I Built You a Tower tour. Ben Gibbard and his bandmates brought a terrific mix of older favourites and new material, with Gibbard in particularly good spirits throughout the show.
Opening the evening were Melbourne trio Acopia, bringing their dreamy blend of pop and electronic music to the arena. You’re No Good for Me opened proceedings, followed by Talk About It and Toxic Traits, with Holding On and See You in Everyone also featuring early on. The atmospheric songs left plenty of space for their vocals and electronic textures, before Intentions and Falter brought the set towards its conclusion.
Death Cab For Cutie opened with Riptides from their new album, moving straight into Roman Candles before the opening of The New Year drew a huge cheer from the crowd. There was an immediate sense of familiarity between the band and the audience, although Gibbard was quick to acknowledge just how long it had taken them to get back. After Punching the Flowers, which featured an incredible mid-song guitar solo, he told us, ‘It has been seven years since we’ve been here and that’s way too fucking long. That’s on us.’
Gibbard brought plenty of energy to the early part of the set. The Ghosts of Beverly Drive was an early favourite, with Gibbard dancing around the stage, while Black Sun was particularly enjoyable live and ended with the crowd singing together. Introducing their latest album with I Built You a Tower (a), he thanked Melbourne for the warm welcome and joked that the city was ‘exactly like Seattle but you drive on the wrong side of the street’.
A welcome surprise came with Photobooth, which received a big audience reaction, followed by the newer Pep Talk. Gibbard was in a playful mood, making light of the number of shows happening around town and reminding the audience that they were neither Benson Boone nor Iron Maiden. The tone shifted for What Sarah Said, with Gibbard singing from behind the keyboard as the haunting piano parts settled over the rest of the band.
The first genuinely stripped-back moment arrived with I Will Follow You Into the Dark. Alone with an acoustic guitar, Gibbard pointed out that this was the first time they’d played in an arena in Australia, and asked for the house lights to come on so everyone could sing together. He even promised an additional chorus to give the audience its money’s worth. The result was a lovely communal moment, made funnier when he followed it with ‘take that Iron Maiden’.
Then came I Will Possess Your Heart – and what a performance it was. The long, unmistakable bass introduction was allowed to unfold, giving the band room to build the song patiently before Gibbard’s vocals finally arrived. It remains one of our absolutely favourite songs to listen to, and a highlight of the evening. Grapevine Fires was another welcome inclusion; introduced as a song about the American West, before Stone Over Water and the strobe-lit opening of How Heavenly a State returned the focus to the newer material.
The familiar opening of Cath… drew another big cheer, with Gibbard also taking the opportunity to thank Acopia. Crooked Teeth was another personal favourite from the band’s earlier years, while Trap Door brought back Gibbard’s wonderfully unselfconscious dancing. By You Are a Tourist, the set had moved through an impressive range of the catalogue without losing momentum. Acoustic guitars came out for Soul Meets Body, although Gibbard ended up tossing his aside mid-song and continuing to sing. He had already summed up the mood rather well; ‘this has been a fucking blast’.
The encore was an especially rewarding selection for longtime fans. Title Track and A Movie Script Ending reached back into the band’s earlier catalogue, before Gibbard introduced Tiny Vessels by explaining that his parents usually enjoy the band’s music, but this particular song’s lyrics had upset his mum. Finally, Transatlanticism brought the night to a close; its gradual build giving the arena one last chance to lose itself in the music.
For all the affection attached to the older songs, this was far more than a nostalgia exercise. The new material sat comfortably beside favourites that have endured for decades, while Gibbard’s humour, restless movement and unmistakable voice gave the performance its personality. Before leaving, he promised Melbourne would not be kept waiting another seven years. We are counting down the days to their return.

